"When that sign comes down after all these years, there'll be a tear in my eye for sure." — Mike Rothwell, quoted by MercerMe
He made that remark in May, a few weeks before he closed the doors of Pennington Quality Market for the last time. He wasn't being dramatic. Three generations of Pennington families did their weekly shopping under that sign. Then, over two days in the middle of June, it came down anyway.
Here's what didn't come down: the Saturday morning crowd at the farmers market up the road. The taps inside the 1700s barn on Titus Mill Road. The growers who show up every week whether the anchor grocery store down the street is called Pennington Quality Market or something else entirely. If you measured Pennington's food identity by its biggest sign, this was the year everything changed. If you measured it by what residents actually do on a Saturday, almost nothing did.
Forty-Five Years, Sixty-Six Years, One Weekend
That word "anchor" is worth pausing on, because it explains why the sign mattered enough to make people emotional in the first place. The market has sat at 25 Route 31, at the corner of West Delaware Avenue, since 1960, when the McVeigh family moved the business to that spot. That's where the 66-year figure attached to this story comes from. Larry Rothwell bought the business from the McVeighs in September 1981, and it's his family's name most current Pennington residents actually grew up associating with the store. That's the 45-year number you'll see in other write-ups. Both are accurate. They're just measuring different clocks, and neither one is wrong.
Either way, June 13 to June 15, 2026, marked the first ownership change most current Pennington residents have ever seen at that address. The store closed for a couple of days and reopened as McCaffrey's Food Markets, the ninth location for a family-owned chain that has operated out of Lower Bucks County since 1986. Every PQM employee was offered a position with the new owner.
"We are honored to welcome Pennington Quality Market into the McCaffrey's family," Jim McCaffrey IV said in the announcement. One notable parallel is this: McCaffrey's runs its own version of the fundraiser that helped build PQM's reputation in the first place. The company's Grocer Fights Cancer Day, started by Jim McCaffrey III after his sister's cancer diagnosis, has raised more than $550,000 for the American Cancer Society over the years. Two family grocers, a state line apart, built the same tradition independently, long before anyone was negotiating a sale.
The Market Up the Road Never Blinked
Walk a few minutes north from that same corner and you're standing on the lawn at Rosedale Mills, 101 Route 31 North, where the Pennington Farmers Market has run every Saturday morning for years, sale or no sale. Nothing about the ownership news touched this. The market opened its 15th season on May 27 with fifteen vendors, and its next milestone Saturday, August 15, is Tomato and Corn Day, the market's annual celebration of the two crops that define a New Jersey August.
Regular vendors like Cherry Grove Farm, Double Brook Farm, and Bent Spoon keep showing up whether the grocery store down the road changes hands or not. One of them, Chickadee Creek Farm, actually farms its fields at 80 Titus Mill Road, the same two-lane stretch that leads to this month's second story.
| Pennington Farmers Market, remaining 2026 highlights | What's happening |
|---|---|
| August 15 | Tomato and Corn Day |
| October 3 | Meet a Chef |
| November 14 | Holiday Bazaar |
| Every Saturday through mid-November | Regular market, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. |
A Few Hundred Yards Down Titus Mill Road
Follow that road past Chickadee Creek's fields and you land at Needle Creek Farm Brewery, set inside a barn built in the 1700s on John Hart Farms. The taproom pours beers named for the land it sits on, including Post & Beam Ale and Hops in the Henhouse IPA, and live music is a regular weekend fixture.
On Sunday, August 16, the brewery hosts something a little different from its usual lineup. Tavern Talks, run by the New Jersey Historical Commission's RevolutionNJ program, turns the taproom into a colonial-era debate. Neighbors, family, and friends with conflicting loyalties surround you, and organizers promise reenactors who connect that history to arguments the town is still having today. It's billed as immersive rather than a lecture, and attendees are told they'll have to decide which side to take. Salt Pepper & Garrlic BBQ, the smoker that's been popping up at Needle Creek through the summer, keeps a rotating schedule worth checking before you head over.
Same Two Roads, Different Kind of Change
Put these three stories next to each other and the pattern is hard to miss. The one change that actually altered a building, a sign, and a payroll happened at a single address on Route 31. Everything within walking distance of that address kept operating exactly as it did the week before. The market didn't relocate. The brewery didn't pause for renovations. The farms on Titus Mill Road didn't skip a Saturday.
That's worth knowing if you've lived in Pennington long enough to feel a pang about the old sign coming down. The store changed hands. The town's food habits didn't.
If you're planning a weekend around this:
- Saturday, August 15, morning: Pennington Farmers Market on the Rosedale Mills lawn for Tomato and Corn Day.
- Sunday, August 16, afternoon: Tavern Talks at Needle Creek Farm Brewery, 91 Titus Mill Road.
- Any weekend after that: the store at 25 Route 31, still staffed by the same people who rang you up under the old sign, now called McCaffrey's.
None of it requires leaving town. It just requires knowing which two roads to be on.
Christina Winka Homes has spent two decades paying attention to those roads, those farms, and the families who run the businesses along them, because that kind of detail is what it actually means to know Mercer County rather than just sell it. If you're curious what day-to-day life looks like in a town like Pennington, or you're thinking about your own next move here, Let's Connect.